(In a diner, Friend 1 is seated in a booth and slowly flipping through a book-long menu)
Friend 1: (Stopping on a page) I wonder what they’d do if someone actually ordered the Surf & Turf Special…?
(Friend 2 hurriedly slides into the opposite booth)
Friend 2: Hi – sorry I’m late; lost track of time.
Friend 1: (Closing the menu) Heh, that’s usually my line.
Friend 2: (Rummaging through pockets) Yeah, I was at the supermarket and took longer than I thought picking out something.
Friend 1: Was it between apples and cookies? That decision gets me every time.
Friend 2: No – this. (Pulls out two lottery scratch-off tickets and slams them down onto the middle of the table)
Friend 1: (Leans down to stare at the tickets for a few seconds, then looks back up at Friend 2) I’m confused – are you actually your evil twin?
Friend 2: That’s not a real question, but to answer the one you meant: yes, I decided to walk on the wild side for a few seconds of my life.
Friend 1: I see that – why?
Server: (Approaches the table) Hi, ready to order?
Friend 1: No, but if I ask you to come back in a few minutes you’ll have moved on to 50 other tables and we’ll see you in an hour instead, so I’ll have a soda and whatever the soup of the day is, please.
Server: Tomato Basil.
Friend 1: Again?
Server: If you’re here regularly enough, then yes.
Friend 1: …All right, I’ll take it. Thank you. (Hands the menu to Server)
Server: (Turns to Friend 2 while taking the menu and writing on a notepad) And for you?
Friend 2: I’ll have a chocolate malt and the Surf & Turf Special, please. (Hands the menu to Server as Friend 1’s eyebrows jump up)
Server: (Takes the menu while still writing) And how’d you like the Turf cooked?
Friend 2: Rare, please.
Server: Options are medium or well-done.
Friend 2: Oh. Medium then, please.
Server: (Nods while writing) Upgrade to sweet potato fries?
Friend 2: Sure, why not?
Server: $3 extra.
Friend 2: Oh. Eh, sure, why not? I mean – go for it!
Server: (Finishes writing) `K, everything’ll be out soon. (Leaves for the kitchen)
Friend 1: OK, now I’m worried: are you dying or something?
Friend 2: Well, if you think about it, we’re all dying. (Friend 1’s eyes widen) I just figured, once in a while, live a little, right?
Friend 1: (Holds up the scratch-off tickets) Wouldn’t happen to have anything to do with these, would it?
Friend 2: Oh right, those. (Takes them back) Yeah, I was picking up the usual groceries, and I was passing the customer service counter when it suddenly hit me: I have never played the lottery in my entire life.
Friend 1: I doubt that; somebody would’ve given you one of those – (Points to the tickets) at some point, they’re the perfect non-gift gift.
Friend 2: The what?
Friend 1: You pay the money for someone to have a chance to win, and if they don’t it’s like you didn’t give them anything. Either way, you’re still out 5 bucks.
Friend 2: Oh, yeah, I guess, but I never actually bought one for myself. So, instead of the state lotto and all those ones where you have to pick your own numbers, since I might’ve changed my mind at that point, I went to the scratch-off machine and got the highest ones they had so if we win we’ll win big, and if we lose it’ll be more fun scratching off the designs than just checking rows of numbers.
Friend 1: OK. “We”?
Friend 2: Yeah: one for you, one for me.
Friend 1: Aw, thanks. How much do I owe you?
Friend 2: Forget it – you’re helping me feel less of a loser by playing these with me.
Friend 1: Oh… thanks?
Server: (Comes back with two drinks) Here you go.
Friend 1 and Friend 2: Thanks. (Each takes a glass)
Server: (To Friend 1) And soup of the day actually is French Onion – you still want it?
Friend 1: (After sipping the soda) Um… how much longer would it be if I changed to a burger instead?
Server: Past the time the Surf & Turf’ll be done.
Friend 1: French Onion it is, then. (Server leaves) So, when’re you going to check the ticket, tonight?
Friend 2: Why not now? (Takes out a wallet, opens a zippered compartment, removes a quarter, pockets the wallet, and starts scratching one of the tickets) You should do it now, too! If you want.
Friend 1: No, I’ll wait till you’re done. (Watches for a few seconds) So, what’ll you do if you win?
Friend 2: (Still scratching the ticket) Ha, probably put it toward groceries.
Friend 1: No, I mean big. What if you win big, and literally win the lottery?
Friend 2: (Trails off scratching) Huh….
Friend 1: I mean, what’s the biggest prize on there?
Friend 2: A million.
Friend 1: Woo-whee! Even with taxes taken out, that’s a nice chunk of change! So what would you do if you actually won it?
Friend 2: (Looks off in thought) I don’t know… invest it, probably.
Friend 1: C’mon, I know you already have retirement funds and all that jazz – Future You’s all set. This – (Picks up the other ticket and waves it in emphasis) is for Present You. And once it gets out there that you won, all your fake relatives who didn’t exist until that moment will appear, looking for a slice of that cash pie, so I say, eat it all now before they get anywhere near it!
Friend 2: (Sets down the quarter) Well, really, I should save some of it –
Friend 1: Heck no! If you didn’t already have a good job, good health insurance, and all that, I’d say yes, invest away. You don’t have any major debts you haven’t told me about, do you?
Friend 2: No.
Friend 1: Even better. This – (Waves the ticket again) would be play money, and I say use it on whatever you want as fast as you can, `cause life’s too short and someone else’ll figure out a way to snatch this from you if you don’t spend it all first.
Friend 2: OK, what about you then?
Friend 1: What about me?
Friend 2: Yeah, what would you do if you won the lottery?
Friend 1: (Leans back, stares at the ticket fondly for a few moments, then stares wistfully into space) Retire.
Friend 2: Ha!
Friend 1: (Looks back at Friend 2) You think I want to spend my mid-life-to-golden-years still working in retail? I’d dump it tomorrow if I could.
Friend 2: Sorry, it’s just – we’re nowhere near retirement age.
Friend 1: And we never will be at this rate. You should retire, too – we could travel the world without worrying about all the e-mails waiting for us on the first Monday morning back.
Friend 2: Wait, two minutes ago you were telling me to keep my job’s salary and benefits and use this – (Waves the ticket) to play!
Friend 1: I’m modifying the scenario. If I retire alone, I’ll get bored – who’ll I hang out with if all my friends are still stuck in the daily grind?
Friend 2: All right, fine, we retire – then what? We can’t live on whatever the amount’ll be after taxes are taken out of $1 million; we probably couldn’t even retire on the full $1 million.
Friend 1: But if we combine the tickets, then it will be $2 million.
Friend 2: It’s still a million each.
Friend 1: Oh right. (Looks at the ticket again) All right, forget the retirement.
Friend 2: For now?
Friend 1: If that makes you feel better. (Taps the ticket against the table-top in thought) Maybe we’re going about this all wrong.
Friend 2: How so?
Friend 1: Maybe we really should just give it all away.
Friend 2: (Raises an eyebrow) You’re suggesting that?!
Friend 1: (Stops tapping) Think about it: nothing good ever comes from a sudden influx of that much money. There are too many horror stories of people ruining their lives, and winding up as degenerates, and fending off all the fake relatives.
Friend 2: You already said that one.
Friend 1: Well, it’s worth repeating. Those stories never have a happy ending, and everyone always winds up wishing they’d never bought the ticket in the first place.
Friend 2: I doubt everyone wishes that – those are just the bad stories you hear about.
Friend 1: And I don’t want to be one of them!
Friend 2: So, what, you want me to take the ticket back? (Holds out a hand)
Friend 1: (Holds the ticket closer as Friend 2 pulls back the hand) No, I just… think we should be smart about it so we don’t become another cautionary tale, that’s all.
Friend 2: OK, how about this: we win a million-ish dollars; we donate 99% of it to local food banks, community services, animal shelters, and the like; the remaining 1% we put toward trips to Iceland and New Zealand so we can say we almost travelled Pole-to-Pole and vertically half-circumnavigated the globe; how’s that sound?
Friend 1: (Thinks for a few moments, then nods) Sounds like a plan. (Fishes a quarter out of a pocket and holds it up) Ready?
Friend 2: Ready!
(Friend 1 and Friend 2 lean over and scratch their tickets in a focused frenzy)
Server: (Arrives with a tray of plates, opens up a stand, and places the tray on it) OK, who ordered the Special again?
Friend 1: (Looks up intensely) We’ll-take-care-of-those-thank-you! (Goes back to scratching the ticket; Friend 2 never stopped)
Server: Oh… kay…. (Leaves for another table, muttering) I’ll need all that stuff back, you know….
(After several minutes, Friend 1 and Friend 2 finish scratching their tickets and stare at them)
Friend 2: All of mine are one-digit off from the winning numbers.
Friend 1: I think I won.
Friend 2: Really?!
Friend 1: (Looks closer at the ticket) Wait, no, never mind – mine are all one-digit off, too.
Friend 2: Oh. Not even a free ticket pity prize?
Friend 1: Nope. You?
Friend 2: Nope. This really is a non-gift gift, huh.
Friend 1: Well, it’s the thought that counts.